The view from offshore
离岸观点
Here, Carey Olsen managing partners Anthony McKenzie (Singapore) and Michael Padarin (Hong Kong) reflect on significant events and trends of 2022, how they have impacted the offshore legal market in Asia and how they will continue to shape the year ahead.
凯瑞奥信管理合伙人麦安腾(新加坡办公室)和彭德贤(香港办公室)在本文回顾了 2022 年的重大事件和趋势,并分析它们如何影响了亚洲地区的离岸法律市场,以及将它们如何继续影响来年的业务。
Looking back on 2022, what were some of the major events/trends that impacted the work you did as an offshore law firm? Do you see these impacts being felt going into 2023?
Anthony McKenzie (AM): 2021 was a blockbuster year for many offshore law firms in Asia. Booming deal flow saw revenues and profits surge. In order to service their clients, law firms increased their headcount. Fast forward to 2022 and beyond and the economic outlook is very different. Asia deals are being threatened by geopolitics, interest rate hikes, spiralling inflation, supply chain disruption, and slowing growth, especially in China which is Asia’s largest offshore legal market.
Michael Padarin (MP) : The growing acceptance of digital assets as a 'mainstream' asset class had a material impact on the corporate work we did during the early part of 2022, where we were involved in assisting with the launch of multiple Cayman Islands domiciled investment funds which focus on digital assets, Web 3 and blockchain related projects. We were also involved in a good deal of regulatory advice for virtual asset service providers looking to commence business in the jurisdictions in which we operate. The 'crypto winter' that blew in from around mid 2022 slowed activity on a number of digital asset related projects and looks to continue into 2023, or until there is a strengthening in sentiment and pricing of digital assets.
Are there any other macroeconomic changes such as rising inflation and a worry of the global economy slipping into a recession impacting the growth for offshore firms in 2023? How do you think the US-China standoff along with the Russia-Ukraine war impact growth in 2023?
MP: These macroeconomic factors are having a huge impact on deal certainty in markets across the world and are being felt acutely across Asia. There are a number of factors at play here, including depressed company valuations; inflation, which amongst other things, is depressing certain key global currencies; and lingering restrictions on global travel, which is making it very difficult for dealmakers to meet, conduct diligence on assets and get deals done. Each of these factors is impacting deal flow and we have seen a real slow down in M&A activity which is not forecast to rebound significantly in 2023.
What are some of your predictions for trends and developments you expect to see in major Asian markets in 2023, such as Singapore, Hong Kong, mainland China and others?
AM: For clients and law firms alike, the decision to base operations in markets such Hong Kong, Mainland China, Singapore or elsewhere must be considered not only by looking at each region’s strengths and weaknesses, but also how they fit into a broader strategy for Asia. Shenzhen continues to grow and is becoming more open to international business, while Shanghai remains China’s commercial and financial capital. Despite recent geopolitical developments, Hong Kong will likely continue to be an essential contributor to any successful China strategy.
With China’s economy slowing, Singapore is closer to the next wave of fast-growing economies in Southeast Asia and is ideally situated as a regional hub for international businesses. It has also become Asia’s leading tech, private client and asset management hub. As a result, we are seeing regional, international and offshore law firms fast expanding their footprint in Singapore or opening new offices there.
MP: The ripple effect of distress in the Chinese real estate market is being felt across Asia. Particularly in our contentious practice, we are seeing an increase in shareholder disputes, insolvencies and restructuring transactions, and expect these types of work will continue strongly in 2023.
What are some of the jurisdictions and industry sectors where you expect to see strong demand for your services in the next year? What will be driving this demand?
AM: The next 12 months will likely be characterised by continued caution in terms of deployment of capital and opportunistic investment. However we expect that investors in the region will continue to allocate capital to alternatives. There’s still so much dry powder sitting on the sidelines and Asian private equity funds have continued to increase in size, despite global economic uncertainty. We are seeing such PE funds shift their focus away from China towards Southeast Asia because of China’s slowing growth, continued Covid-zero policies and geopolitical tensions. India, another Asian giant, will also benefit from such a shift.
Asia now accounts for the highest number of UHNWIs in the world. Many UHNWIs and affluent families have flocked to Singapore in recent years as a base to park their wealth. Singapore’s draw is a confluence of a number of factors, including its stability, rule of law, favourable tax rates and ease of doing business. Family offices in Singapore are gaining traction mostly due to the desire of wealthy families to institutionalise and diversify their family programmes. We continue to see tailored trust and family office structures being set up in Cayman, Jersey and BVI for HNW Asian families.
We have also seen an increase in instructions related to distressed structures, businesses and assets in Asia. As a result we continue to invest in our Asian litigation, restructuring and insolvency practice as US-China tensions continue to mount and Asian businesses deal with global uncertainty and the aftermath of the pandemic.
MP: In the investment fund space, we continue to see the Cayman Islands as the dominate jurisdiction of choice. It has a long established reputation for quality and is well recognised globally. Attempts by Hong Kong and Singapore in recent years to introduce competing funds regimes have not had a material impact on the continuing strength of the Cayman Islands offering.
What are some of the major laws and regulations you are looking ahead to in 2023 in onshore Asian markets that will impact your clients and their business? Likewise, what about major offshore jurisdictions such as BVI and Caymans
AM: Cayman and BVI continue to be the preferred offshore choices in the Asian market. Bermuda is also an established offshore jurisdiction with a number of Hong Kong and Singapore listed companies incorporated there.
However recently we have seen Asian clients becoming increasingly interested in tapping into UK and European markets via other offshore jurisdictions such as Jersey and Guernsey. In addition, a number of Singapore-based managers are now using Jersey as the jurisdiction in which to domicile their crypto funds because of Singapore and Jersey tax considerations, including potential relief available under the Singapore-Jersey Double Tax Agreement.
Carey Olsen is the only offshore firm with a dedicated ‘Channel Islands desk' which is based in our Singapore office.
MP: In the BVI, a virtual asset service providers regime is to be introduced next year which we expect will generate significant interest from Asia based crypto service providers and will drive business to our regulatory practice which has been very active advising in the virtual asset space.
In the Cayman Islands, new transparency legislation is being discussed which (if fully implemented) will mean additional disclosures on ownership and control of Cayman Islands entities. This is likely to impact on both our clients and also the operation of our business in the Cayman Islands.
In addition, we expect that the new restructuring regime in the Cayman Islands (being a Restructuring Officer sitting outside of the liquidation wrapper) is likely to be a focus in 2023.
How are you planning to grow/adapt your presence in Asia/Asia-related work as a result? What is your strategy for your Asian services offering going forward?
AM: This is a time of unique opportunity to reshape the way lawyers work with their clients and rethink the structure and scale of our practice areas, sectors and geographic locations. Our Singapore and Hong Kong offices have continued to grow and evolve and are among the fastest growing in our global network. We have launched a trust and private client practice in Asia, welcomed several senior lateral hires, made a number of new promotions and we expect this to carry on into 2023 and beyond as we continue our growth trajectory in Asia.
In an increasingly complex and fluid geopolitical environment, clients require multidisciplinary, real-time solutions to business challenges. Our top priorities now (and going forward) are to continue to invest in our people and to be innovative in how we connect and engage with those clients, meet their commercial needs and address the challenges they are facing.
MP: The growth in insolvency and restructuring work has also meant we're looking to significantly add to the head count in this area. One of our Hong Kong office USPs is on the ground Bermuda advice on contentious and non-contentious restructuring matters, which is particularly relevant given the number of legacy Bermuda companies listed on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange. We'll look to continue to strengthen our expertise in this area as it is a key differentiator in this market.
This is our full response to the Q&A from Asian Legal Business (ALB) for the article Offshore View 2023 in the November 2022 issue of the ALB magazine.
回顾 2022 年,哪些重大事件或趋势影响了离岸律师事务所的工作?您认为这些影响是否会持续到 2023 年?
麦安腾(Anthony McKenzie,以下简称为 AM):对于许多在亚洲的离岸律师事务所而言,2021 年是个精彩的一年。交易流量激增带来了营收和利润飙升。为了服务客户,律师事务所纷纷增加了团队人数。进入2022 年及之后,经济前景则迥然不同。亚洲地区的交易正面临地缘政治、加息、通货膨胀飙升、供应链中断和增长放缓的威胁,特别在中国这个亚洲最大的离岸法律市场,情况更是如此。
彭德贤(Michael Padarin,以下简称为 MP):人们接受把数字资产当作“主流”资产类别的程度日渐提升,这对我们在 2022 年初开展的公司业务产生了重大影响,我们参与协助推出了多个在开曼群岛注册,主要以数字资产、Web 3 和区块链相关项目为重点的投资基金。此外,我们还与在我们运营的司法管辖区开展业务的虚拟资产服务供應商提供了大量與监管相关的法律建议。“加密货币寒冬”在 2022 年中期悄然来袭,减缓了一些数字资产相关项目的活动,这影响可能会持续至 2023 年或直至数字资产的情绪指数和定价有所上涨为止。
在 2023 年,是否有任何其他宏观经济变化(如不断加剧的通货膨胀和对全球经济陷入衰退的担忧)会影响离岸律所的发展?您认为中美对峙以及俄乌战争对 2023 年的发展有何影响?
MP:这些宏观经济因素对全球市场的交易确定性产生了巨大影响,在亚洲地区感受尤其明显。當中涉及几个因素,包括公司估值低迷,通货膨胀及其他因素,压制某些关键的全球货币;以及全球出行的持续限制,导致交易人员难以会面、对资产开展尽职调查並完成交易。这些因素都对交易流量产生了影响,而我们也看到并购活动已有所放缓,预计在 2023 年不会出现明显回升。
您对 2023 年亚洲地区主要市场(如新加坡、香港、中国大陆等)的趋势和发展作何预测?
AM:对客户和律师事务所而言,在决定是否在香港、中国大陆、新加坡或其他市场经营业务时,不仅要考虑每个地区的优势和劣势,还要考虑它们如何融入更广泛的亚洲战略。深圳持续发展对国际企业秉持越来越开放的态度,而上海仍然是中国的商业和金融中心。尽管最近地缘政治发展,香港可能继续成为任何成功的中国战略的重要贡献者。
随着中国经济的放缓,新加坡更接近东南亚下一波快速增长的经济体,作为国际商业区域中心,它的地理位置优越。同时也成为了亚洲領先的科技、私人客户和资产管理中心。因此,我们发现许多区域、国际和离岸律师事务所在新加坡迅速扩展业务或开设新的办公室。
MP:整个亚洲地区都感受到了中国房地产市场低迷带来的连锁反应。特别是在争议解决业务中,我们发现股东纠纷、破产和重组交易有所增加,并且预计此类业务将在 2023 年继续保持强劲势头。
您预计在未来一年中,哪些司法管辖区和行业会对贵所提供的服务产生强劲需求?驱动因素有哪些?
AM:在未来 12 个月,我们可能需要继续在资本部署和机会投资方面保持谨慎态度。然而,我们预计亚洲投资者会继续将资金划拨给另类投资。尽管全球经济不稳定,但仍有大量累积待投现金被搁置在一旁,此外亚洲地区的私募股权基金仍在继续扩大规模。我们看到,由于中国的增长放缓,持续实施新冠肺炎清零政策以及地缘政治局势紧张,这些私募股权基金将其重心从中国转移向东南亚。另一个亚洲大国印度也将从这转变中受益。
目前亚洲的超高净值人士 (UHNWI)占全球之首。近年来,许多超高净值人士和富裕家庭纷纷涌入新加坡,将其作为存放财产的主要基地。新加坡所的吸引力来自多个因素的汇合,包括其稳定性、法治、有利的税率和经商便利度。新加坡的家族办公室越来越受关注,其主要原因在于富裕家庭希望使其家族计划制度化和多元化。我们留意到,开曼群岛、泽西岛和英属维尔京群岛 (BVI) 不断为亚洲高净值 (HNW) 家庭设立量身定制的信托和家族办公室结构。
我们还发现,与亚洲地区的不良结构、业务和资产相关的业务委托有所增加。因此,随着中美局势持续紧张、以及亚洲企业应对全球经济不确定性和疫情余波,我们将继续投资于亚洲的诉讼、重组和破产业务。
MP:在投资基金方面,我们看到开曼群岛仍被视为首选司法管辖区。开曼群岛因卓越质量而久负盛名,并在全球范围内得到了高度认可。近年来,香港和新加坡尝试引入竞争性基金制度,但并未对开曼群岛业务的持续優勢产生实质影响。
2023 年亚洲在岸市场推行的主要法律法规中,您认为其中哪些会对贵所的客户及其业务产生影响?同样地,英属维尔京群岛和开曼群岛等主要离岸司法管辖区将呈现何种局面?
AM:开曼群岛和英属维尔京群岛仍是将亚洲市场的首选离岸业务地区。百慕大也是一个成熟的离岸司法管辖区,许多香港和新加坡的上市公司都是在那里注册成立。
然而,我们最近发现亚洲客户对通过泽西岛和根西岛等其他离岸司法管辖区进入英国和欧洲市场的兴趣日渐上升。此外,由于新加坡和泽西岛的税收考虑(包括新加坡与泽西岛签订避免双重征税协定的潜在减免),许多常驻新加坡的基金经理现在使用泽西岛作为注册其加密货币基金的司法管辖区。
凯瑞奥信是唯一一家在新加坡办公室设有专门的“海峡群岛服务处”的离岸律师事务所。
MP:英属维尔京群岛将于明年推行虚拟资产服务提供商制度,我们预计这将引起亚洲加密货币服务提供商的极大兴趣,并将推動我们的监管业务,我们一直非常积极地为虚拟资产领域提供法律咨询服务。
开曼群岛正在讨论新的透明度立法。如果全面实施,这将意味着对开曼群岛注册公司的所有权和控制权进行额外披露。这可能会影响我们的客户以及我们在开曼群岛的业务。
此外,我们预计开曼群岛推行的新重组制度(在不参与清盘程序的情况下担任重组官)可能会成为 2023 年的焦点。
基于上一个问题,您计划如何加强或调整贵所在亚洲的相关业务?就未来在亚洲提供的服务而言,贵所会采取什么战略?
AM:我们将利用这一难得的机会重塑律师与客户合作的方式,重新思考我们的业务领域、行业和地理位置的结构和规模。我们的新加坡和香港办公室不断发展壮大,现已成为我们全球网络中发展最为迅猛的两个办公室。我们在亚洲推出了信托和私人客户业务,迎来了几位资深高级人员,并晋升多位律师。随着我们在亚洲持续发展,我们预计这种趋势将持续到 2023 年及以后。
在日益复杂多变的地缘政治环境下,客户需要多学科的实时解决方案以应对业务挑战。我们当前(及未来)的首要任务是继续投资于我们的团队人才,并针对如何与客户联系和互动、满足他们的商业需求并以创新方法应对他们面临的难题。
MP:破产和重组业务的增长意味着我们将设法大幅增加这个领域的团队人数。我们香港办公室的优势之一是在百慕大就有争议和无争议重组事宜提供实地法律咨询,鉴于在香港交易所上市的百慕大传统公司的数量,这项服务尤为重要。我们将继续扩展这个领域的专业能力,因這是在香港市场脱颖而出的关键因素。
以上便是我们对《亚洲法律杂志》(Asian Legal Business,简称 ALB)在 ALB 杂志 2022 年 11 月刊中就文章“2023 年离岸见解”(Offshore View 2023) 设定的问答环节的完整回应。